We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.
Somewhere right now, a writer is sitting in a coffee shop with a laptop that costs more than their first car. It has a backlit keyboard, cloud sync, a grammar checker, and seventeen browser tabs open, at least four of which are about whether otters hold hands while they sleep. (They do. You’re welcome.)
At the next table, somebody else is writing a novel with a pen.
It isn’t a stylus, and it isn’t an “e-ink writing tablet with paper-like feel.” It’s a pen, moving across paper the way pens have since before the printing press made scribes nervous. You might assume that person is a romantic, or a Luddite, or that their laptop is in the shop. Sometimes they’re just one of the most successful writers alive.
Writing by hand in the 21st century looks like a quaint affectation. Then you notice how many major books started as ink, graphite, and coffee rings, and the habit starts to look more like a method.
So let’s look at the holdouts, the scribblers and legal-pad loyalists, and at what their pens seem to give them that a keyboard doesn’t.
Stephen King: The Fountain Pen as Physical Therapy
Stephen King has been one of the most prolific writers on the planet for most of his career, and for most of it he’s typed. That makes Dreamcatcher (2001) a strange case.
After he was hit by a van in 1999, sitting at a computer was painful. So King wrote the first draft of Dreamcatcher in longhand, with a Waterman fountain pen, filling notebook after notebook. He has said that working by hand slowed him down and made him think more about each sentence. For a writer whose default speed is “freight train,” that was new.
The result is a long, strange, gross, and oddly tender novel, very much a King book, but written at a different tempo. He has called the fountain pen experience one of the most rewarding of his career. Even the people who write the fastest seem to benefit from a speed bump.
Lesson: A pen won’t make you write better, but it will make you write slower, and sometimes that’s the same thing. [Buy | Read more]
Quentin Tarantino: Felt-Tip Pens and No Computer
Quentin Tarantino doesn’t write novels (well, he does now; Once Upon a Time in Hollywood got a novelization), but his screenplays are some of the most quoted pages of the last thirty years. They start out in notebooks.
Tarantino has long described writing his scripts by hand, often with felt-tip pens, and avoiding a computer at that stage. His reasoning is roughly that you can’t write poetry on a computer: the machine wants things to look finished before you’ve thought them through. A notebook doesn’t care how messy you are.
Typing comes later, after the pages exist. The notebook is where the strange, loud, very specific voices get to happen.
Lesson: The first draft is for you. Nobody needs to read it, including the software. [Buy]
Toni Morrison: Pencils, Legal Pads, and the Hour Before Dawn
Toni Morrison wrote while working full-time as an editor and raising two sons on her own. She wrote early in the morning, before the day got hold of her, and she famously wrote in pencil on yellow legal pads.
There’s something fitting about that. Morrison’s prose is dense and musical, worked line by line, and the legal pad is a humble tool: cheap, portable, and unbothered by how many times you cross something out. She would revise heavily, and the paper kept a record of her changes of mind in a way a cursor doesn’t. A deleted sentence on screen is gone, while a crossed-out one on a legal pad stays visible under the line, waiting in case you want it back.
Lesson: Revision isn’t erasure. Sometimes the best line is the one you crossed out last Tuesday. [Buy | Read more]
John le Carré: The Spy Who Wouldn’t Type
You’d expect the master of Cold War espionage to like tradecraft, and le Carré’s tradecraft was decidedly analog. He wrote his novels by hand, and for decades his wife, Jane, typed up the manuscripts. Then he would mark up the typescript by hand, she would retype it, and so on through the drafts.
He was candid about not trusting computers to give him the feel of the work, and given the plots of his novels, a man who preferred not to leave a digital trail makes a kind of narrative sense. George Smiley would approve.
Lesson: Find the tool that makes you feel like you’re making something, not processing it. [Buy]
Paul Auster: The Notebook and the Olympia
Paul Auster may be the patron saint of analog stubbornness. He wrote his drafts by hand in notebooks, usually with a fountain pen, then typed them up on a manual Olympia typewriter he had owned since the 1970s. He loved that machine enough to write a whole book about it, The Story of My Typewriter (2002), illustrated with paintings of it by artist Sam Messer.
Auster described the pen as feeling closer to the body. The words seemed to come out of his hand rather than off a keyboard. It’s a mystical way of putting it, but many hand writers say something similar: the pen feels like part of their own handwriting, and the keyboard feels like dictating to a machine.
Lesson: If your tool is a good one, keep it until the ribbon factory closes, then write a book about it. [Buy]
Joyce Carol Oates: Writing Longhand at Absurd Speed
If you think writing by hand means writing slowly, Joyce Carol Oates is the counterexample. She’s one of the most prolific American writers ever, with dozens of novels and a short-story count that’s hard to tally, and she drafts in longhand.
So the pen isn’t a brake for her. It seems to be how she gets her ideas flowing. She has talked about working out a whole novel in her head and in handwritten notes before she ever types, sometimes while running or walking. Handwriting is part of a process that is very much about thinking, and the typing comes after.
Lesson: A pen doesn’t make you slow. It makes you deliberate, and deliberate people can be scarily fast. [Buy]
J.K. Rowling: Napkins, Notebooks, and Handwritten Spreadsheets
The origin story is famous enough to be its own small legend: a struggling single mother writing in Edinburgh cafés, with Harry Potter’s world taking shape in longhand. Much of the series’ early drafting was done by hand. Rowling’s plotting charts are just as interesting: hand-drawn grids tracking chapters, timelines, and which secret gets revealed where. They’re essentially spreadsheets made on lined paper.
For a series built on clues planted years before they pay off, that kind of tactile planning makes sense. You can’t foreshadow a seven-book mystery while trying to remember which folder you saved Book Three’s notes in.
Lesson: Even the most magical worlds need a plot grid, and you’re allowed to draw yours with a ruler. [Buy | Read more]
Robert Caro: The Biographer and His Legal Pads
Fiction writers aren’t the only ones. Robert Caro, the Pulitzer-winning biographer behind The Power Broker and the multi-volume life of Lyndon B. Johnson, writes his first drafts in longhand on legal pads. Then he types them on a Smith-Corona typewriter. Caro has said he chooses handwriting partly to slow himself down, because he naturally writes fast and the pen forces him to think.
He also outlines in enormous detail, famously pinned to the wall of his office, so that he knows exactly where a book is going before he gets lost in thousands of pages of research. Caro’s books are huge and meticulous and have taken decades. He doesn’t hurry the work, and his tools don’t either.
Lesson: If you’re going to spend twenty years on a book, you may as well enjoy how the pen feels. [Buy]
Jennifer Egan: Longhand for the Experimental
Here’s a fun contradiction. Jennifer Egan’s A Visit from the Goon Squad (2010) is remembered partly for its chapter told as a PowerPoint presentation, about as screen-native as literary fiction gets. Egan has said she typically writes her first drafts of fiction by hand.
That makes the point nicely. The tool you draft with doesn’t limit what you can imagine, and might even free it up. A slide deck about the pauses in rock songs, written by a woman with a pen, is the kind of thing that makes literature fun.
Lesson: Analog process, avant-garde product. No contradiction required. [Buy]
So Why Do They Do It?
Ask enough hand writers, and the same reasons keep coming up.
It’s slower, in a good way. The hand can’t keep up with the brain, so the brain has to pick. Every sentence goes through a small filter just by being physically harder to produce.
There’s no internet in a notebook. You can’t check your email on a legal pad, and that alone may account for half the novels finished in this century.
It keeps the mess. Crossed-out lines, arrows, margin notes, doodles: handwriting records the thinking, not just the final result. Delete a paragraph on a laptop, and it’s gone. Strike it out on paper, and it’s still there if you want it.
It turns typing into a second draft. Nearly every writer above eventually types the handwritten pages. That transfer is a built-in revision pass. You can’t type up your own sentences without judging them.
It feels like making something. This one is harder to measure, but writers keep saying it. A pen is a craftsman’s tool, and a notebook full of your own handwriting is a physical object you made.
There’s even a bit of science behind the hunch. In a much-discussed 2014 study, psychologists Pam Mueller and Daniel Oppenheimer found that students who took lecture notes by hand did better on conceptual questions than those who typed. Typists tended to transcribe word for word, while hand writers were forced to summarize and process. It was a study about note-taking, not novel-writing, but the principle carries over: when you can’t copy everything, you have to understand it.
Should You Write by Hand?
Maybe. Maybe not. Plenty of brilliant writers type everything, and a few seem to write entire novels on their phones, which I respect the way I respect people who run marathons in sandals.
The real lesson from these writers isn’t “pens good, laptops bad.” It’s that your process is a choice. The default tool isn’t always the right one. If you’ve been staring at a blinking cursor for an hour while the cursor stares back, it might be worth getting out a cheap notebook and a pen you like and seeing what happens when the words have to come through your hand.
Worst case, you end up with a notebook full of bad sentences. Best case, you’re in company with King, Morrison, le Carré, and the woman at the next table in the coffee shop who just finished chapter twelve.
Either way, the otters will still be holding hands.
Do you write by hand, type everything, or switch between the two? Tell us about your process in the comments, and let us know which pen you’d defend to the death.
Discover more from A Book Geek
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


















